Sooz’s Guide to Revisions, Lesson 4: Planning the attack.
So, you figured out what your Perfect Book would be in Lesson 3. Now we’re going to take that and apply it to your novel.
This part is fun–like, no joke, this step is one of my favorites for the ENTIRE novel-writing process. You’re calling on your left-brain for organization, and you’re calling on your right-brain for creativity.
Plus, by creating this Plan of Attack, you are ensuring you get through revisions as quickly as you possibly can. There’s a reason I meet all my editorial deadlines early, and this is it.
Supplies Needed Today:
- Your outline (either in index cards or printed/written out)
- Multicolored post-its or sticky-tabs (as I mentioned in Lesson 1, I color-code everything)
- Your Plot Holes worksheet
- Your fan letter to yourself
- Your Perfect Book worksheets
- Your Other Problems worksheets
Fixing Plot Holes
As you may recall from the Intro, we approach our manuscript hierarchically. Biggest problems taper down to little things, and the biggest problem of all is plot.
Why? Because plot–or the events in the story–affects your novel’s structure. You might be adding scenes, cutting scenes, rearranging scenes, rewriting scenes, etc., and if you spend time tweaking a character only to cut the scene…well, that’s an inefficient use of your time.
1. So, take your Plot Holes worksheet, your Perfect Book synopsis, and your outline. What you are going to do now is figure out WHAT you have to add in/subtract to make your novel into the Perfect Book.
2. There are two ways to approach this:
- By Plot
- You separate your outline based on which plot and subplot it falls into. To do this, you will need to:
- Sort out how many subplots you have and assign them a letter (or #, name).
- Start with the main external plot, so take all cards that apply to that plot thread, and stack them up.
- Once you finish this step with the main plot, you’ll put the cards back together and pull out all cards that have to do with subplot A (or whatever you named it).
- Move down until you’ve covered every plot.
- I recommend this step if it is your FIRST TIME REVISING.
- You separate your outline based on which plot and subplot it falls into. To do this, you will need to:
- In Order
- Simply move from one card to the next in order.
- You have to have a pretty good feel of how your plots and subplots are working together, so I don’t recommend this step to beginners. If you are a MORE EXPERIENCED writer/reviser, then this step might work for you.
3. You are now going to sort out what needs to be added and what needs to be removed. (If you wish to use a worksheet, then head here. You will need to transfer all this information onto your outline.)
4. Using blue (or whatever your Plot Color is) post-its or sticky-tabs, you’re going to make a quick note about what must be added (or removed) and you will stick it onto the specific scene’s index card.* (See the picture–BUT, keep in mind, I ran out of white index cards, so the color of the index card here has no significance.)
*Note: if you wish to write more than you can fit on a post-it note, then feel free to code your post-its and write a full summary elsewhere.
5. If you are going to ADD a scene, then you’ll get a new index card and fill it out just like the rest of your outline. I like to make sure I know it’s a new scene by adding some blue around the edges.
If you are going to REMOVE a scene, remove it from the stack (don’t lose it, though! You might change your mind).
6. Keep adding blue post-its/stickies until you reach the end of the outline and have worked through every plot thread.
Fixing Characters and Relationships
7. Get your Fixing Character worksheets and your outline.
8. There are two ways to approach this:
- By Character
- You separate your outline based on which character appears in the scene. To do this, you will need to:
- Sort out how many characters you have that need fixing.
- Start with the biggest character (if your main character needs tweaking then it will be him/her), so take all cards in which that character appears, and stack them up.
- Once you finish this step with that character, you’ll put the cards back together and pull out all cards that have to do with next biggest character.
- Move down until you’ve covered every character that needs fixing.
- I recommend this step if it is your FIRST TIME REVISING.
- You separate your outline based on which character appears in the scene. To do this, you will need to:
- In Order
- Simply move from one card to the next in order.
- You have to have a pretty good feel for when your character appear, so I don’t recommend this step to beginners. If you are a MORE EXPERIENCED writer/reviser, then this step might work for you.
9. You are now going to sort out what needs to be changed. What about the way this character acts/speaks/interacts must be altered so this character can become the person you want them to be. Keep your Fixing Character worksheets handy for this!
10. You will also be dealing with character relationships here. If the romance isn’t what you wanted, if the mother/daughter relationship isn’t coming across right, or if the villain is just too cruel to the hero, you’re gonna deal with that here.
11. Using pink (or whatever your Character Color is) post-its or sticky-tabs, you’re going to make a quick note about what must be changed about the character and you will stick it onto the specific scene’s index card. (See the picture–notice it has 2 PLOT and CHARACTER post-its.)
12. Keep adding pink post-its/stickies until you reach the end of the outline and have worked through every character and relationship.
Fixing Setting
13. Get your Fixing Setting worksheets and your outline.
14. There are two ways to approach this:
- By Setting
- You separate your outline based on which setting in which a scene is set. To do this, you will need to:
- Sort out how many settings you have that need fixing.
- Start with the biggest setting (the setting that mos frequently appears in the novel–and is therefore, the most important), so take all cards in which that setting appears, and stack them up.
- Once you finish this step with that setting, you’ll put the cards back together and pull out all cards that have to do with next biggest setting.
- Move down until you’ve covered every setting that needs fixing.
- I recommend this step if it is your FIRST TIME REVISING.
- You separate your outline based on which setting in which a scene is set. To do this, you will need to:
- In Order
- Simply move from one card to the next in order.
- You have to have a pretty good feel for the setting’s weight, so I don’t recommend this step to beginners. If you are a MORE EXPERIENCED writer/reviser, then this step might work for you.
15. You are now going to sort out what needs to be changed. What about the way this setting appears, the way the story/characters interact with it, must be altered so the setting is vivid and compelling. Keep your Fixing Setting worksheets handy for this!
16. Keep in mind that the less important a setting is, the less time you should devote to describing it. If only one scenes is set there, then it shouldn’t warrant much description. If half the book is set there, then you need to get pretty detailed.
17. Using green (or whatever your Setting Color is) post-its or sticky-tabs, you’re going to make a quick note about what must be changed about the setting and you will stick it onto the specific scene’s index card. (See the picture–notice there are now PLOT, CHARACTER, and SETTING post-its.)
18. Keep adding green post-its/stickies until you reach the end of the outline and have worked through every setting.
Fixing Other Stuff
19. This is for all that other stuff you dealt with.
20. With orange post-its (or whatever color you want), you’ll go through every single scene card and point out if something needs to be tweaked.
21. For example, if a scene you know you’ll be keeping is just plain TOO SHORT, you’ll indicate that.
Putting it all Together
22.Put all your scene cards back together and in order. You’ve got a new outline–an outline for the Perfect Book!
23. Your outline should be VERY colorful now! And you should be very PROUD now! You just did a lot of work, and now you’re ready to get started on the actual REVISING.
Wrapping up
In the next lesson, we’ll be taking our new outline and getting started with writing in our changes. There are two approaches to doing this, and once I explain those, you’ll be ready to sink your teeth into your novel!
So for now, get started planning your attack! Go team!
And if you have ANY questions, ask them in the comments!!
Lesson 1 → Lesson 2 → Lesson 3 → Lesson 4 → Lesson 5 → Lesson 6 →
linda
May 18, 2011 @ 9:18 am
Wow, this series is AMAZING! Thanks for taking the time to detail your revision process — there are so many great tips and instructions here. I love how organized you are. I’m just starting out, but I think I’d prefer to write my rough draft as an outline first, so I’ll be trying to adapt some of your ideas into a pre-writing outline instead of saving it all for the revision. But yeah, thanks for the awesome posts!
Susan
May 18, 2011 @ 10:48 am
Good luck with your outline! I hope it saves you time! 😀 I had a really strict outline for SOMETHING STRANGE AND DEADLY, and I even stuck to it on the first draft. But, on the second draft, I realized it wasn’t the story I wanted to tell anymore, so I pretty much rewrote the whole thing!! AHAHAHA, so much waaaasted time. Clearly, I was NOT meant to be a plotter…though I’m not 100% a pantser either.
I’m sure you’ll do better than me, though–not hard to do. 😉
Jules
May 18, 2011 @ 9:52 am
These are so great, Sooz! Well done! I will certainly refer back to these suggestions once I’m in the revising stage. It makes me wish I had a complete manuscript to work with now – though admittedly I think much of this wish stems from wanting to use color-coded highlighters and post-its. 😀
Susan
May 18, 2011 @ 10:48 am
Oh yes, the colors are NICE!! 😀
Laura Hughes
May 18, 2011 @ 10:37 am
Another fabulous post! I was just wondering, do you send your book to various CPs before or after this process?
Susan
May 18, 2011 @ 10:51 am
No! I don’t want to waste my CPs time by giving them my first drafts… To be honest, my first drafts are riddled with plot holes, dropped threads, and crappy writing–no one deserves to be subjected to that!!
I send the second draft–so what I produce after this revising–to my CPS. I rely on CPs to find problems that I might not be able to catch myself, such as confusing world-building, a tiny plot hole, character inconsistencies, or slow/rushed pacing.
Then, after it’s been through the trusted CP, it goes to my agent…who will have comments of her own. 🙂 PLUS, once it sells (gotta think positive–not if sells, I have editorial revisions to deal with.
As I’ve said before: Writing is for me, revising is for my readers! 😀
Meredith
May 18, 2011 @ 2:51 pm
This is awesome. This really speaks to the color-coding/hyper-organized control freak living deep inside of me. I can see now how awesome the note card method is. So … yeah. I’m totally going to use note cards (and sticky notes!) next time.
Out of curiosity, do you use this method for every draft or just for first drafts?
Susan
May 18, 2011 @ 3:07 pm
I use this method for every BIG revision round. So, if a second draft has serious issues, I’ll use this. If I’m dealing with minor things (like, fore example, the comments you gave me on SS&D), I won’t use this method. And if it’s just line-edits, I won’t use this method.
That said, I used approach this for both rounds of my editorial revisions on SOMETHING STRANGE AND DEADLY, and guess what: both times I turned it in WEEKS early. 🙂
Adriana
May 18, 2011 @ 4:10 pm
It’s taken me forever to comment on your series :C But I finally sat down yesterday and read them all! (After a mind-twisting session of MCAT studying–you would think graduating would give me some free, no-studying time. Apparently not.)
You are so organized! Seriously. I like the color-coding and the flash cards! It actually seems do-able. Imagine that. Lol. It made me want to write 🙂 And now I shall go finish my first draft, so that I can apply all your handy-dandy advice. I love the worksheets, by the way 😀
And I can see how the organizing and preparing would make it easier to revise a manuscript. I HAVE been one of those who spent hours fixing a scene and then totally ended up cutting it out. Ugh.
Thanks for sharing this, though! 😀
Loves,
A
P.S.: Just out of curiosity: Do you speak French? I’m trying to learn, but I’m trying to figure out where to start or what program to use, since going to France isn’t necessarily an option right now 😉
Susan
May 18, 2011 @ 5:24 pm
Doable = yay! I get so easily daunted by all the HARD WORK in a book that I HAD to break it apart if I ever wanted to tackle it.
re: French, yes. Some. I taught myself French for ~1 year, but then the Frenchman and I moved to GERMANY. So…French training stopped, and I dove into German. That said, whenever I visit the Frenchman’s family, I get a TON of immersion, and a lot of it comes back. I’d say (if you can afford it) Rosetta Stone is really effective…but it takes time–like, you don’t start out with useful phrases. Another option is Pimsleur (also expensive, though I can send you mine–email me!!). That program taught me most of the French I know now… NEXT, and the most FUN, is FRENCH IN ACTION–and it’s totally free! Just google it watch the videos online. 😀
Heather
May 18, 2011 @ 9:16 pm
Thanks for taking the time to write all these revision posts, they’re sooo awesome and helpful. I’m a nerd for sticky notes and colour co-ordination 🙂
I’m trying to revise my first draft, but it’s in third person and I think it would work so much better in first person. I remember reading that you originally wrote SOMETHING STRANGE AND DEADLY in third, but later changed it to first (I’m not a stalker, I swear). Out of curiosity, did you rewrite it entirely for that draft? Would this method of revising still work for a complete rewrite? I’m kind of intimidated by all the work I have to do.
Susan
May 18, 2011 @ 9:41 pm
To answer your question about POV, here’s what I did:
First, I went through the WHOLE manuscript and changed “she/Eleanor” to “I”, and the occasional “they” to “we”. I also corrected any incorrect tenses. THEEEEN, I went through and read it all. I did NOT follow this method because I really had to change the entire novel, and the only change was: add more voice.
If you think about it, first person is more than just “I”. It’s direct access to thoughts, and more importantly, it’s the whole world filtered through that person’s brain. I had to add in more reactions to Eleanor’s world, more thoughts to her life and feelings, and more of her voice. I can’t lie: it took a while. But at the same time, it’s not that tricky once you get a good sense of the voice. You build a rhythm and start to see where reactions/thoughts/voice go.
A minor thing I also had to fix was “naming”. Basically, I had to cut a lot of the names. No longer did I need to refer to “Mama” every time she appeared–I could just call her “she”. Does that make sense?
And, to now stop rambling and fully answer the darn question: YES, you could totally do this as you revise. Just keep in mind that you will need to do it for every single scene in addition to the other changes you’re making.
Don’t be intimidated!! It’s 100% manageable. Just go scene by scene, index card by index card, and you’ll reach the end in no time. 😀
Rochelle
July 12, 2013 @ 9:35 pm
Hi Sooz, I know I’m late to these posts (NaNo brought me here), but I’m loving your series on revision and following it. I just don’t know what to do about color-coding and separating out plots.
See, in the first 1/10 or so, I world-build. The MC has an unobtainable goal, and her conflict right now is mainly that she wants to pursue that goal and can’t. Then something happens and she’s sent to a place where she CAN pursue her goal. But in pursuing that goal, she finds out something happened to her family where she came from and she wants to go back to see what she can do.
To me, that’s all the main plot, even though it has three different goals.
Then I have a subplot in the middle where her love interest tells her to avoid a group of people and she has to spend time with them anyway and that creates tension in her relationship. But then in the last leg of the main plot, those people are the only ones willing to find out what happened to her family. At that point, do I say it’s part of subplot and plot? Or do they all get joined together into main plot only?
And then many scenes have tension and conflict created by the interactions of the people around the MC. I’m not sure if it (a) counts as a subplot, since their tension drives along the storyline and serves as a foil for the MC and her love interest; (b) doesn’t count as a subplot but does count as tension in individual scenes; or (c) is drivel and all conflict should include the MC.
Sorry for the long post, but I’d love advice from anyone who can help me sort out what’s going on here…
beezyalona_pjel
December 25, 2013 @ 1:24 am
H1fd The Last few years I used to be so very lacking in $$ and debts were eating me from all sides. That was RIGHT UNTIL i found out how to generate money.. on the internet! I went to surveymoneymaker point net, and started filling in surveys for straight cash, and surely I’ve been far more able to do my things! i’m very glad i did this! vSc
Alysha Beers
May 29, 2016 @ 4:40 am
THANK YOU! This was so extremely helpful! Better than any self-editing book I have ever read (and I’ve read a lot). You’re so sweet for putting all of this information out there for aspiring authors! I cannot thank you enough! Also, you are an amazing writer! 🙂